The What If? Thread

[nodnerg]

Me and my buddy where thinking of random battles and we came up with this
If Juggy cant be stopped while in motion and Blob(before H.O.M) cant be moved when grounded what would happen.
And if Pyro can control fire could he de-power sunfire (or rogue now/or anyone fire based).
can anyone think of similar ones. Keep in mind this is just for fun

[Shauny7488]

There was an issue of X-Men that had Juggernaut charging toward the Blob, only to have Blob get out of the way at the last minute. The fans didnt like that, so they made a What If out of it. Basicly, Juggs hit Blob, Blob exploded, but his feet were still on the ground, unmoved. Personally i would have voted to have a hole in the space-time continuum rip open and everything get sucked through it

[Quentin Hex]

hmm,i would expect either marvel's outcome, or a giant explosion, because all of that displaced momentum has to go somewhere. that's my theory at least.

[Dihan]

The first is similar to the Omnipotence Paradox and a Chinese proverb about a spear that can pierce any shield and a shield that can deflect any strike. Logic says that an unstoppable object or being cannot exist at the same time as an immovable object or being otherwise they are not what they say they are. However there are a few theories I've heard:

1) The unstoppable object bounces off the immovable object.
2) The unstoppable object stops whilst the immovable object moves.

For the second, technically Pyro can't control Sunfire's fire because Sunfire's power isn't fire - it's solar radiation and plasma. A better question would be Pyro vs the Human Torch. I think it would be a draw:

1) They can both control fire.
2) They are both immune to fire in some way.

However, Pyro is only immune to fire that's under his control so he'd have to always be on the defensive; taking control of any fire that comes near him.

[LX - Rampage]

Whoa, sounds smart Dihan. Really, it wasn't offense, it did sounds smart. I stay in a normal writing style. Juggernaut would win, Sunfire would win.

[Rain]

juggernaut vs blob... juggernaut can win because hes unstoppable
pyro vs sunfire... sunfire should win because is kinda flames god, pyro can only controle the fire not create it

[Ztony]

idd juggernaut win, and can't pyro control the fire? meaning he can control human torch ?

[Tooxor]

if human torch stop the "flame on mode", pyro can't control he

they must fight without power...

[Ztony]

then it comes down to the martial arts skills of those 2