The "Heroes You Want" list (now 45 heroes total)

[Enchantress]

As long as Jean Grey is avilable on all systems, I'm good.

[Emilio Amaral]

1.Hulk
2.Thing
3.Colossus
4.Thor
5.Ironman
6.Wolverine
7.Spider-Man
8.Black Panther
9.Cyclops
10.Jean Grey
11.Storm
12.Archangel
13.Nightcrawler
15.Captain America
16.Cable
17.Mr. Fantastic
18.Invisible Woman
19.Human Torch
20.Sabretooth
21.Magneto
22.Juggernaut
23.Dr. Doom
24.Venom
25.Silver Surfer
26.Iceman
27.Psylocke
28.Bishop
29.Rogue
30.Mr. Sinister
31.Gambit
32.Beast
33.Omega Red
34.Luke Cage
35.Moon Knight
36.Daredevil
37.Punisher
38.Nick Fury
39.Green Goblin
40.Rhino
41.Scarlet Witch
42.Havok
43.Vision
44.Mistique
45.Professor Xavier

[The Raptor]

1. Black Panther
2. Black Widow
3. Blade
4. Cable 
5. Captain America 
6. Crimson Dynamo (Unlockable)
7. Daredevil 
8. Dazzler 
9. Deadpool 
10. Dr. Strange 
11. Echo 
12. Falcon
13. Ghost Rider 
14. Green Goblin
15. Hawkeye 
16. Hercules
17. Hulk 
18. Human Torch 
19. Invisible Woman 
20. Iron Fist
21. Iron Man 
22. Luke Cage 
23. Mr. Fantastic 
24. Moon Knight 
25. Namor 
26. Nick Fury
27. Nova 
28. Psylocke 
29. Punisher 
30. Quicksilver 
31. Scarlet Witch 
32. Shadowcat 
33. She-Hulk 
34. Silver Surfer   
35. Spider-Man 
36. Storm 
37. Sunfire 
38. Thing 
39. Thor
40. Tigra
41. Venom 
42. Vision 
43. Wolverine 
44. Wonder Man
45. X-23 

[Buddhabear100]

1. Spider-man
2. Daredevil
3. Luke Cage
4. Electra
5. Ghost Rider
6. Iron Fist
7. Dr. Strange
8. Moon Knight
9. Captain America
10. Iron Man
11. Hulk
12. Thor
13. Giant-Man/Ant-Man
14. The Wasp
15. Ms. Marvel
16. Black Panther
17. Hawkeye
18. Sentry
19. Namor
20. Human Torch
21. Mr. Fantastic
22. Invisible Woman
23. The Thing
24. She Hulk
25. Deadpool
26. Cyclops
27. Iceman
28. Storm
29. Nightcrawler
30. Colossus
31. Wolverine
32. Beast
33. Jean Grey
34. Silver Surfer
35. Nick Fury
36. Black Widow
37. Punisher
38. Spider-Woman
39. Black Bolt
40. Quicksilver
41. Scarlet Witch
42. The Vision
43. Black Cat
44. Wonder Man
45. Angel

[colossusjames]

First off, I want the option to play two different teams:

For:
1. Iron Man
2. Mr. Fantastic
3. She-Hulk
4. Ms. Marvel
5. Tigra
6. Doc Samson
7. Spiderman
8. Lady Deathstrike
9. Wonder Man
10. Thor
11. Venom
12. Green Goblin
13. Bishop
14. Bullseye
15. Sentry
16. Stature
17. Wasp
18. Giant Man
19. Moonstone
20. Screaming Mimi

Against:
1. Captain America(Patriot costume)
2. Daredevil
3. Wiccan
4. Wolverine
5. Storm
6. Hercules
7. Vision
8. Invisilble Woman
9. Human Torch
10. Punisher
11. Black Panther
12. Spider Woman
13. Namor
14. Thing
15. Hulk
16. Cable
17. Hawkeye(Young Avenger)
18. Dagger
19. Luke Cage
20. Hulkling

[Sammo12345]

1) Captain America   
2) Wolverine   
3) Spider-Man   
4) Ironman    (I had Thor here but when i read the word four and then Thor it sounded funny lol)
5) Thor   
6) Storm   
7) Invisable Woman   
8) Mr. Fantastic   
9) The Thing   
10) Human Torch   
11) Jean Grey 
12) Nightcrawler   
13) Colossus   
14) Gladiator 
15) Quicksilver   
16) Scarlet Witch 
17) Vision 
18) Ghost Rider 
19) Black Panther 
20) Shadowcat 
21) Emma Frost 
22) Cyclops 
23) The Hulk 
24) Daredevil 
25) Spider-Woman 
26) Rogue  OR Ms Marvel (Both their powers are too simular, obviously)
27) Sunfire 
28) Hawkeye 
29) Wasp 
30) Angel 
31) Beast 
32) Iceman 
33) Silver Surfer 
34) Captain Britain 
35) Blade
36) Doctor Strange 
37) Luke Cage 
38) Havok 
39) Polaris 
40) Banshee
41) She-Hulk 
42) Gambit 
43) Guardian (Alpha Flight, hey why can't Canadian Superheros play too. I dunno why they're so unpopular, I like them!)
44) The Punisher 
45) Multipleman 

[Wings of the Phoenix]

Confirmed:

1) Captain America
2) Iron Man
3) Spider-man
4) Wolverine
5) Thor
6) Daredevil
7) Hulk
8) Mr. Fantastic
9) Thing
10) Invisible Woman
11) Human Torch
12) Luke Cage
13) Storm
14) Green Goblin
15) Venom

Completing the 24 characters-list:

16) Jean Grey
17) Cyclops
18) Silver Surfer
19) Ms. Marvel
20) Punisher
21) Dr. Strange
22) Magneto
23) Dr. Doom
24) Black Widow

My dream 45 character-list:

Heroes:

25) Ghost Rider
26) Blade
27) Elektra
28) Spider-Woman
29) Black Panther
30) Deadpool
31) Scarlet Witch
32) Quicksilver
33) She-hulk
34) Psylocke
35) Gambit
36) Iceman
37) Colossus
38) Namor

Villains:

39) Enchantress
40) Mystique
41) Dr. Octopus
42) Mysterio
43) Mandarin
44) Bullseye
45) Sandman

[xwolvie]

I'd like:

1. Spider-Man (Spider-Man)   
2. Black Cat (Spider-Man)
3. Iron Man (Avengers/Illuminati) 
4. Hulk (Avengers) 
5. Thor (Avengers) 
6. Captain America (Avengers) 
7. She-Hulk (Avengers) 
8. Wasp (Avengers) 
9. Giant Man (Avengers)
10. Vision (Avengers) 
11. Ms. Marvel (Avengers) 
12. Hawkeye (Avengers) 
13. Spider-Woman (Avengers) 
14. Captain Marvel (Avengers) 
15. Ronin (Avengers/Marvel Knights) 
16. Luke Cage (Avengers/Marvel Knights) 
17. Iron Fist (Marvel Knights) 
18. Daredevil (Marvel Knights) 
19. Ghost Rider (Marvel Knights) 
20. Dr. Strange (Marvel Knights/Illuminati) 
21. Punisher (Marvel Knights) 
22. Black Panther (Marvel Knights/FF/Avengers) 
23. Elektra (Marvel Knights) 
24. Wolverine (X-Men/Avengers) 
25. Cyclops (X-Men) 
26. Colossus (X-Men) 
27. Rogue (X-Men)      (preferred character...)
28. Iceman (X-Men) 
29. Nightcrawler (X-Men) 
30. Storm (X-Men/FF) 
31. Psylocke (X-Men) 
32. Shadowcat (X-Men) 
33. White Queen (X-Men) 
34. Professor X (X-men/Illuminati) 
35. Black Bolt (Illuminati) 
36. Namor (Avengers/FF/Illuminati) 
37. Moonstone (Thunderbolts)
38. Songbird (Thunderbolts) 
39. Venom (Thunderbolts/Spider-Man) 
40. Bullseye (Thunderbolts) 
41. Green Goblin (Thunderbolts/Spider-Man) 
42. Mr. Fantastic (FF/Illuminati)
43. Invisble Woman (FF) 
44. Human Torch (FF) 
45. Thing (FF) 

I think this is a good roster: every team is represented by at least 4 members but I confess that it lacks of villains (that I don't like very much).   

[sypher2008]

i personally dont think they should include the originals because that was the first game so they should a whole new set of good characters and heres my pick:

1: Adam Warlocke
2: Thanos
3: Galactus
4: Odin
5: Dr Doom
6: Pyro
7: Mystique
8: Apocalypse
9: Angel
10: Venom
11: Carnage
12: Magneto
13: Blob
14: Hulk
15: Onslaught
16: Professor X
17: Phoenix
18: Holocaust
19: Genesis
20: x-man

unlockables:

1: Toad
2: Quicksilver
3: Warstar
4: Deathstrike
5: Mikhail
6: Kitty Pryde

story lines should include the infinity war and infinity gauntlets.

i know this looks far fetched but to be honest, there is no point paying another 50 bucks for the same characters regardless of the direction they undergo.
a little creativity is in order and the use of the ever expanding world of marvel.
it will make the games longer and more enjoyable.
thats just my opinion though i dont expect anyone to agree but just respect it. thanks guys

[jonchang]

Just FYI dude, a majority of the characters are waaaay too overpowering.

[Spider-phoenix]

These are the 45 charecters I want to be playable :

1. Angel   

2. Beast 

3. Black Panther

4. Blade 

5. Cable   

6. Captain America   

7. Captain Marvel   

8. Colossus 

9. Cyclops 

10. Daredevil   

11. Deadpool 

12. Doctor Strange 

13. Elektra 

14. Emma Frost 

15. Gambit 

16. Ghost Rider   

17. Guardian   

18. Havok 

19. Hawkeye   

20. Hulk 

21. Human Torch

22. Iceman 

23. Invisible Woman 

24. Iron Fist 

25. Iron Man 

26. Jean Grey 

27. Luke Cage 

28. Miss Marvel  

29. Mister Fantastic 

30. Moon Knight 

31. Namor 

32. Nightcrawler 

33. Punisher 

34. Quicksilver 

35. Scarlet Witch 

36. Silver Surfer 

37. Spider-Man   

38. Spider-Woman   

39. Storm 

40. Thing 

41. Thor   

42. Venom   

43. Vision 

44. Wasp 

45. Wolverine 

[marvelfan12345]

1.   Captain America – Classic, Ultimate, Ex-Patriot, WWII, US Agent, Modern
2.   Iron Man – Modern, Ultimate, Classic, Original, War Machine, Heroes Return
3.   Thor – Modern, Classic, Ultimate, Asgardian Armor, Beta Ray Bill, Thunderstrike
4.   Mr. Fantastic – Modern, Classic, Ultimate, New Marvel, Retro, Street
5.   Invisible Woman – Modern, Classic, Ultimate, New Marvel, Retro, Malice
6.   Human Torch – Modern, Classic, Ultimate, New Marvel, Retro, Street
7.   Thing – Modern, Classic, Ultimate, New Marvel, Original, Mutated
8.   Spider-Man – Classic, Symbiote, Stark Armor, 2099, Fantastic Four, Spider-Carnage
9.   Wolverine – Astonishing, Classic, Original, Ultimate, Street, New X-Men
10.   Hulk – Classic, Original, Planet Hulk, War World Hulk, Red Hulk, Joe Fixit
11.   Storm – Astonishing, Classic, Original, Retro, Ultimate, X-Treme
12.   Luke Cage – Modern, Classic, New Avenger, Street, Ultimate, The Raft
13.   Daredevil – Classic, Original, Armored, Marvel Knights, Movie, Ultimate
14.   Black Panther – Modern, Classic, Original, Holy Armor, Retro, Ceremonial
15.   Spider-Woman – Classic, S.H.I.E.L.D., House of M, Ultimate, Julia Carpenter, Spider-Girl
16.   Elektra – Classic, Retro, Ultimate, Stealth,  Movie, Team-Up
17.   Ghost Rider – Classic, Original, 2099, Vengeance, Phantom Rider, Johnny Blaze
18.   Dr. Strange – Classic, Original, Ultimate, Royal Seer, Strange, Blue Mage
19.   Silver Surfer – Classic, Norrin Radd, Golden Avenger, Power Cosmic, Ultimate, Silver Savage
20.   Iceman – Classic, Ultimate, Human, Retro, Spiky, Original
21.   Deadpool – Classic, Marvel Girl, Ultimate, Unmasked, Weapon X, X-Men
22.   Ms. Marvel – Classic, Original, Modern, Binary, Rogue, Sharon Ventura
23.   Colossus – Modern, Ultimate, Human, Classic, Astonishing, Outback
24.   Moon Knight – Modern, Classic, Retro, Ultimate, Khonshu,  Moonshade
25.   Green Goblin – Classic, Movie, Hobgoblin, New Goblin, Thunderbolts, Norma Osborn
26.   Venom – Classic, Thunderbolts, Ultimate, Marvel Knights, Carnage, Toxin
27.   Songbird – Modern, Classic, Thunderbolts, Street, Original, Screaming Mimi
28.   Hawkeye – Classic, Modern, Thunderbolts, Golden Archer, Ultimate, Street
29.   Scarlet Witch – Modern, Classic, Gypsy, Ultimate, The Crossing, West Coast
30.   Jean Grey – Phoenix, Dark Phoenix, Ultimate, Classic, Original, Retro
31.   Quicksilver – Modern, Classic, Original, Ultimate, The Crossing, Retro
32.   Cyclops – Astonishing, Classic, Original, Ultimate, Retro, Street
33.   Sentry – Modern, New Avenger, The Raft, Battle-Damaged, Original, Masked
34.   Nightcrawler – Astonishing, Modern, Ultimate, Classic, Uncanny, Priest
35.   Emma Frost – Modern, Astonishing, Classic, Original, Generation X, New X-Men
36.   Wasp – Modern, Ultimate, Classic, Retro, Original, Heroes Return
37.   Captain Britain – Modern, Classic, Original, Excalibur, Britain, Retro
38.   Shadowcat – Astonishing, Classic, Original, Ultimate, S.H.I.E.L.D., X-Treme
39.   She-Hulk - Modern, Classic, Original, Fantastic Four, S.H.I.E.L.D., Attorney
40.   Nick Fury – Classic, Howling Commandos, Retro, Ultimate, General Fury, Street
41.   Black Widow – Modern, Ultimate, Yelena Belova, Classic, Original, Jacketless
42.   Punisher – Modern, Capunisher, 2099, Classic, Original, Ultimate
43.   Iron Fist – Classic, Original, Retro, Modern, Tournament, Ultimate
44.   Namor – Modern, Classic, King of Atlantis, Street, Ultimate, Captain
45.   Beast – Astonishing, Ultimate, Human, Original, Classic, Retro

others i wanted to add

giant-man, moonstone, quasar, gambit, angel, rogue, vision, hercules, cable, black bolt and atlas

[BlackSun23]

1. Cable
2. Deadpool
3. Cloak
4. Dagger
5. Electro
6. Lionheart
7. Warmachine
8. Psylocke
9. Avalanche
10. Spiderman
11. Carnage
12. Gambit
13. Moon Knight
14. Quicksilver
15. Sunspot
16. Omega Red
17. Morph
18. Blackbolt
19. Taskmaster
20. Namor
21. Punisher
22. Vision
23. Sunfire
24. Hellion
25. Multiple Man
26. Blink
27. Chuck Norris
28. Nocturne
29. Black Tom Cassidy
30. Dead Girl
31. Nova
32. Longshot
33. Shadowcat
34. Juggernaut
35. Marrow
36. Blackheart
37. Ant Man
38. Hawkeye
39. Proteus
40. Shocker
41. Doctor Octopuss
42. Emma Frost
43. Ironman as Hulkbuster
44. Mr. Sinister
45. Magik

[Darkwarrior2093]

1 Emma Frost 
2 Psylocke
3 Storm
4 Magma
5 Polaris
6 Jean Gre
7 Jubilee 
8 Rogue 
9 Dazzler 
10 Gambit 
11 Ciclops 
12 Marvel girl 
13 Elektra 
14 Banshee 
15 Spiderman 
16 x-23 
17 Wolwerine 
18 19 20 21 fantastic four   
22 Nick Fury 
23 Hawkeye 
24 LUke Cage 
25 Iceman 
26 Scarlet Witch 
27 Namor 
28 Blade 
29 black Widow 
30 black panther 
31 Captain America 
32 Ms Marvel 
33 Spiderwoman 
34 Surge 
35 Hellion 
36 Hawok 

[zmikey08z]

1 Emma Frost 
2 Psylocke
3 Storm
4 Magma
5 Polaris
6 Jean Gre
7 Jubilee 
8 Rogue 
9 Dazzler 
10 Gambit 
11 Ciclops 
12 Marvel girl 
13 Elektra 
14 Banshee 
15 Spiderman 
16 x-23 
17 Wolwerine 
18 19 20 21 fantastic four   
22 Nick Fury 
23 Hawkeye 
24 LUke Cage 
25 Iceman 
26 Scarlet Witch 
27 Namor 
28 Blade 
29 black Widow 
30 black panther 
31 Captain America 
32 Ms Marvel 
33 Spiderwoman 
34 Surge 
35 Hellion 
36 Hawok 

Maybe a little less X-Men? It's MUA2, not XML3. I LOVE X-Men. I mean i realy realy REALY LOVE X-Men, but even I realise there has to be less.